Bagels is a Pegasus located in Ponydale between the marketplace and the river. When spoken to, he will tell the player roughly to leave him alone. The reason for his behavior is not currently known. His attitude is similar to that of Sawbuck.
- "Beat it, if ya know what's good for ya!"
- A bagel is a boiled and baked yeast-raised bread item in the shape of a doughnut-like ring.