Geizhufe states that he is waiting on a late delivery, and therefore can't go and get food, and is getting rather hungry, and has a craving for a pie. He'll ask the player to get a Cherry Pie from Sugarcane Corner, and give the player eight bits to purchase one. (Since the pie only costs six bits, the player may keep the additional two bits.)
The player will then have to go to the Sugarcane Corner in Ponydale via the Train and purchase the Cherry Pie he asked for, and return to him in Cantermore.
If the player give him the wrong pie, he gives the player no extra rewards, but if the player give him a Cherry Pie, he will reward the player the quest's reward
If the quest was completed successfully, Geizhufe will repay the player five bits and a wearable empty pie tin hat. (With the excess two bits from earlier in the quest, this amounts to seven bits total.) 1000 XP will also be rewarded to the player