Hullabaloo has asked me to retrieve a basket from Flan at the Paso Fino Cafe.
- Get basket from Flan.
After retrieving the basket:
I got the basket from Flan. Now I just need to take it back to Hullabaloo.
- Take basket back to Hullabaloo.
After delivering the basket to Hullabaloo:
I delivered the basket to Hullabaloo, but the cookies are missing. I should ask Flan if she knows why.
- Ask Flan about missing cookies.
After asking Flan:
I need to find Cirrus, Scribble, and Geizhufe and talk to them.
- Ask Cirrus about the cookies.
- Ask Geizhufe about the cookies.
- Ask Scribble about the cookies.
- Talk to Geizhufe, Scribble, and Cirrus.
After talking to Cirrus, Scribble, and Geizhufe:
- Ask Wayward about the cookies.
After talking to Wayward:
Wayward ate the cookies but he claims the sign said something different than what Flan claims to have written. I should return to Flan and see if she still has the sign.
- See if Flan still has the sign.
After talking to Flan:
I need to ask Cirrus and Scribble if either of them altered the sign.
- Ask Cirrus about the sign.
- Ask Scribble about the sign.
- Ask Cirrus and Scribble about the sign.
After asking Cirrus and Scribble:
I have asked the suspects about the sign. I should return to Flan with my findings
After returning to Flan:
- Get sample from Scribble.
- Get sample from Cirrus.
After collecting hoofwriting samples:
I have the hoofwriting samples from Scribble and Cirrus. I need to return them to Flan.
- Return samples to Flan.
After returning samples to Flan:
Cirrus's hoofwriting sample was a match! I should confront him about this immediately.
- Confront Cirrus.
After confronting Cirrus:
I solved the mystery and made Cirrus pay for the cookies. Now I just need to get the money I spent back to Hullabaloo.
- Return money to Hullabaloo.
I solved the mystery and gave Hullabaloo back his money.
At the start of the quest Hullabaloo tasks the player to pick up the "Paso Fino Perfect Party Pastry Pack" from Flan. Upon giving the pack to Hullabaloo, it is discovered that the cookies are gone, and the player has to find out who is the cookie thief,
Upon talking to Flan again, she reveals that she had let three ponies into her store before the cookies were stolen, which are Scribble, Cirrus and Geizhufe. The player has to then talk to these three ponies; Geizhufe reveals that Wayward was in the shop instead of him, whom the player has to talk to as well. Wayward will reveal that the sign in the store states "do steal" and it was him who ate the cookies, upon which the player have to return and update Flan on the status.
Flan will then check the sign and reveal that the sign wasn't what she wrote, and the player will have to look for the true culprit who changed the sign by obtaining their handwriting. The player will then have to talk to Scribble and Cirrus again to collect their handwriting before returning to Flan yet again.
The handwriting will then be compared by Flan, and the culprit is found out to be Cirrus based on the handwriting from his diary. The player will then have to find Cirrus again, at which point Cirrus will then admit that the true culprit was him and that he will compensate Hullabaloo.
The player then has to return to Hullabaloo and give him the compensation, after which Hullabaloo will give the player a reward for completing the quest.
There is a known bug that when talking to Wayward, players may get stuck in the "I can't talk right now and don't stomp so hard" dialogue tree which cannot be exited directly. To get around this, the player must first talk to Cirrus in Cloudopolis and then return and talk to Wayward.
- During April 2015 stress test, it was impossible to progress beyond Wayward's "Don't stomp so hard" dialogue tree, making the quest impossible to complete. It was fixed with the August 2015 update.
- In the January 2016 Open Server Event, extensive quest journal support was added for this quest, though the implementation is still slightly incomplete and the journal may not mark the quest as completed upon completion.
- Some of the entries and tasks appear to be missing from the journal.